NFU Cymru's view

NFU Cymru remains clear the regulations, which in effect introduce a Nitrate Vulnerable Zone across the whole of Wales, are not fit-for-purpose and are impacting on both farm business viability and the health and well-being of farmers who continue to grapple with this complex and costly piece of legislation.  However, it seems it would be  unwise to assume that the review will deliver a regulatory regime that is less burdensome.  Indications are, in fact, that Welsh Government is looking to ramp up regulation, for example, proposing in the Sustainable Farming Scheme consultation, that the results of potassium and phosphorus analysis will also need to be incorporated into the regulations’ already onerous record-keeping requirements. 

Of course, the review is needed, not least because Welsh Government has only committed to the Enhanced Nutrient Management Approach for 2024 and a long-term sustainable solution to the 170 kg/ha Nitrogen (N) limit from livestock manures is needed. 

Ahead of the review, NFU Cymru will hold Welsh Government to its commitment, as part of the co-operation agreement with Plaid Cymru, to undertake a specific Regulatory Impact Assessment considering the economic and environmental impacts of the 170 kg/ha N limit. 

We will oppose in the strongest terms any proposals that add to the regulatory burden on farmers. We are clear the review must provide the opportunity to bring positive improvements to the regulations so that they are workable and achievable for Welsh farmers.  Welsh Government must also honour its commitment to provide £20m to support compliance with the regulations without delay.